Land & Buildings Investment Management LLC, an activist investment firm with less than a 1% stake in Invitation Homes Inc., is pressuring the single-family rental housing giant to return at least $2 billion in capital to shareholders annually, citing what it considers a significant gap between the company’s stock price and the value of its real estate holdings.
In an open letter dated Nov. 16, Jonathan Litt, founder and chief investment officer of the Stamford, Conn.-based firm, criticized Invitation Homes’ board and management for what he described as complacency, poor capital allocation, and a lack of urgency in addressing the company’s stock valuation. The Dallas-based real estate investment trust (REIT) has a market value of approximately $15.5 billion.
“INVH is among the most undervalued companies in the REIT sector,” Litt wrote, arguing that Invitation Homes’ board has failed to take necessary steps to close the gap between its stock price and the underlying value of its properties.
Land & Buildings estimates Invitation Homes’ net asset value at approximately $45 per share, more than 65 percent above its current share price. The firm said it individually evaluated more than 90 percent of the company’s wholly owned homes and estimated their average value at approximately $425,000 each.
Land & Buildings is recommending that Invitation Homes commit to returning at least $2 billion annually through stock repurchases or dividends, funded by selling individual homes, for as long as its shares trade below estimated net asset value.
The firm also urged the company to offer existing renters a 6-percent rebate toward a home down payment to encourage homeownership and significantly reduce acquisitions and development activities until its stock valuation improves.
Litt argued that Invitation Homes could generate greater shareholder value by selling homes individually to homebuyers rather than continuing to expand its rental portfolio. He also criticized the company for continuing to acquire properties between 2022 and 2025 despite what he described as an unfavorable cost of capital.
The letter also questioned the company’s board oversight and executive compensation, noting that Invitation Homes has paid more than $79 million to resolve four legal matters involving its treatment of residents and business practices, including a $48 million settlement with the Federal Trade Commission in 2024.
Litt also pointed to more than $25 million in special retention awards granted to the CEO and three other executives in March.
Additionally, Land & Buildings criticized the board’s Nov. 11 appointment of Colin Connolly, CEO of Cousins Properties, saying the board should have added a director with greater shareholder representation and capital allocation expertise.
“Just last week,” Litt wrote, “members of the board reiterated their conviction in the status quo, informing us that they believed the board was performing well and refreshment was not needed. Yet days later the board announced the addition of a new director with duplicative skill sets, rather than a director that brings the necessary shareholder alignment and capital allocation expertise the board is sorely lacking.
“We are disappointed by this pattern of disingenuous engagement and believe it is time for all shareholders to evaluate the case for change,” he wrote.
Litt also said it had held other private discussions with Invitation Homes management and board members over several months but hasn’t yet received a satisfactory response.
“We have engaged privately and in good faith with management and the board, sharing detailed analyses and specific recommendations with the hopes of working constructively with the company to drive shareholder value creation,” wrote Litt. “Yet our concerns have consistently fallen on deaf ears, as management and the board have continued down their chosen path of complacency despite the perspectives of Land & Buildings, other shareholders, and sell-side analysts who cover the company.”
“While we remain open to working constructively with the company, we will not hesitate to take whatever steps we believe are necessary to maximize value for the benefit of all INVH shareholders,” he added.
In a Nov. 16 statement, a spokesperson for Invitation Homes said its board and management remain focused on long-term shareholder value and improving the experience of its residents.
“Invitation Homes’ Board of Directors and management team are committed to acting in the best interests of the company and its shareholders to deliver long-term, sustainable value,” the company said.
Invitation Homes also cited consistent demand, strong resident retention, and recent operational and financial performance as evidence of its strategy’s progress, and acknowledged its discussions with Land & Buildings, saying board members and management had held numerous conversations with the firm over the past several months.
“While we are disappointed that Land & Buildings has chosen to make its issues public at this time, we remain open to further engagement,” the company said.